While undoubtedly Doctor Who's weakest decade on the television, there are still gems to be found out there. The top three would certainly be able to walk into any of the other decade lists compiled for this blog. Unfortunately the strength in depth simply isn't there - this period was Doctor Who at its most inconsistent, and like many people, I place the blame for this firmly at the door of the producer and his choice of script editors. Nevertheless, below is a selection of stories which frequently showcase Doctor Who at its most (successfully) experimental, and in the case of the McCoy stories, provide pointers for where the franchise would ultimately head post-cancellation.
1. The Curse of Fenric

Year: 1989
Episodes: 4
Regulars: Sylvester McCoy, Sophie Aldred
Notable Guest Stars: Dinsdale Landen, Alfred Lynch
Writer: Ian Briggs
Director: Nicholas Mallett
Producer: John Nathan-Turner
Unusually for original-series Doctor Who, a real emotional rollercoaster of a tale, with a relentless pace and plenty of memorable characters and scenes. Like all good Doctor Who serials should have, it has a couple of cracking cliffhangers, a strong central villain, and some stirring incidental music, all things it has in common with my number 2 choice...
2. The Caves of Androzani

Year: 1984
Episodes: 4
Regulars: Peter Davison, Nicola Bryant
Notable Guest Stars: Christopher Gable, John Normington
Writer: Robert Holmes
Director: Graeme Harper
Producer: John Nathan-Turner
Peter Davison's swansong contains by far the best writing, acting and directing seen in the show for many years, and unfortunately it would be several more before anything else would come close to touching it again. A dark and gritty story in which the Doctor is little more than a doomed and helpless bystander to the events taking place around him, it bequeathed us several less impressive Colin Baker era rip-offs, but still stands as a mightily impressive production, and possibly the best final story any Doctor has ever had.
3. Ghost Light

Year: 1989
Episodes: 3
Regulars: Sylvester McCoy, Sophie Aldred
Notable Guest Stars: Ian Hogg, Michael Cochrane
Writer: Marc Platt
Director: Alan Wareing
Producer: John Nathan-Turner
The story which, along with its two immediate successors, made a fan of me when it was first broadcast. Despite being fairly impenetrable to the unattentive viewer, the ambition, classiness and evocative atmosphere of this story make it one to cherish.
4. Survival

Year: 1989
Episodes: 3
Regulars: Sylvester McCoy, Sophie Aldred, Anthony Ainley
Notable Guest Stars: Lisa Bowerman, Julian Holloway
Writer: Rona Munro
Director: Alan Wareing
Producer: John Nathan-Turner
The final story of the original run, Survival can't quite match the heights of the previous two stories (see nos 1 & 3), but it shouldn't be put down for that. A lot of the roots of the 21st century revival can be seen here, from the suburban, modern day setting, the exploration of the companion's links to her home, and, um, the use of actors in cat costumes.
5. Remembrance of the Daleks

Year: 1988
Episodes: 4
Regulars: Sylvester McCoy, Sophie Aldred, Terry Molloy
Notable Guest Stars: Simon Williams, Pamela Salem
Writer: Ben Aaronovitch
Director: Andrew Morgan
Producer: John Nathan-Turner
Widely credited with saving the show from a complete creative fizzle out, this serial and its novelisation provided a strong template for the new direction that fan writers would take the franchise in through the nineties. Personally though, I find it hard to get as enthusiastic about it as the other McCoy stories higher up this list, but it is undoubtedly one of the decade's highlights.
6. Enlightenment
.jpg)
Year: 1983
Episodes: 4
Regulars: Peter Davison, Janet Fielding, Mark Strickson
Notable Guest Stars: Keith Baron, Lynda Barron
Writer: Barbara Clegg
Director: Fiona Cumming
Producer: John Nathan-Turner
One of the good things to come out of 80s Who is that it occasionally attempted rather more sedate and cerebral stories like this, which unusually was both written and directed by women - and it shows. Visually lush, and gently inventive.
7. Warriors' Gate

Year: 1981
Episodes: 4
Regulars: Tom Baker, Lalla Ward, John Lesson, Matthew Waterhouse
Notable Guest Stars: Clifford Rose, Kenneth Cope
Writer: Stephen Gallagher
Director: Paul Joyce
Producer: John Nathan-Turner
Again, an experimental story, and not particularly easy to follow compared to most Whos, but contains a host of memorable sequences and images, as well as the departure of both Romana and K9 - the Tom Baker era was finally drawing to a conclusion.
8. State of Decay

Year: 1980
Episodes: 4
Regulars: Tom Baker, Lalla Ward, John Leeson, Matthew Waterhouse
Notable Guest Stars: Emrys James, William Lindsay
Writer: Terrance Dicks
Director: Peter Moffatt
Producer: John Nathan-Turner
A revived script originally due to be submitted back in the mid-late 70s gothic heyday, this is inevitably a (welcome) throwback to a more successful era, and by far the most conventional Who story of the period - in a good way.
9. The Trial of a Time-Lord

Year: 1986
Episodes: 14
Regulars: Colin Baker, Nicola Bryant, Bonnie Langford, Anthony Ainley
Notable Guest Stars: Lynda Bellingham, Michael Jayston
Writer: Robert Holmes, Pip and Jane Baker, Phillip Martin
Director: Chris Clough, Nicholas Mallett, Ron Jones
Producer: John Nathan-Turner
An absolute disaster on so many levels, with a poorly through out structure, plot holes you could drive a train through, and some diabolical writing and acting at some points - but still the most watchable Colin Baker story, and it does have its moments. Just don't think too much about it, and don't set your expectations too high.
10. Kinda

Year: 1982
Episodes: 4
Regulars: Peter Davison, Janet Fielding, Sarah Sutton, Matthew Waterhouse
Notable Guest Stars: Richard Todd, Nerys Hughes
Writer: Christopher Bailey
Director: Peter Grimwade
Producer: John Nathan-Turner
Ok, the rubber snake is rubbish. But even the best Whos have poorly realised monsters. The latest in a long line of Buddhist influenced Who stories is thoughtful and dares to try something a little more imaginative than the norm.